In Switzerland, a country with scarce land and high property prices, the dream of home ownership is increasingly shifting from single-family homes to condominiums. But the purchase of these two types of property could hardly be more different. While you are king of your own plot when you buy a house, when you buy a flat you become part of a compulsory community. The difference between buying a flat and a house becomes apparent not only when you move in, but already when you review the documents and calculate the follow-up costs. Many buyers underestimate how much the rules of a homeowners' association can interfere with their privacy. In this article, we analyse the difference between buying a flat and a house from the perspective of an independent expert, so that you can make a decision that will still be valid in ten years' time.
Egal, welche Fragen du rund um Immobilien hast – Loft ist da, um sie dir übersichtlich, verständlich und zuverlässig zu beantworten.
Stelle Fragen zu einer ImmobilieThe most fundamental difference between buying a flat and a house lies in the legal structure.
This legal difference between buying a flat and a house means that you cannot decide on the exterior of the flat on your own. Do you want to install an awning? The community must agree.
Another difference between buying a flat and a house is evident in the due diligence (careful examination) prior to purchase.
When buying a house, you check the land register extract, the building insurance value and the structural condition. The risk lies solely with you.
When buying a flat, the review is more complex. Here, the difference between buying a flat and a house is striking: you must read the regulations of the condominium owners' association (STWEG) and the minutes of the last three owners' meetings. Why? Because you are joining an existing community. The minutes will tell you whether there are any disputes, whether renovations are pending and whether the neighbours are willing to invest. If you ignore this difference between buying a flat and a house, you often end up buying into the neighbourhood dispute as well.
You will also feel the difference between buying a flat and a house in your wallet.
One key difference between buying a flat and a house concerns the service charge. In a detached house, you pay for what you use (water, electricity, oil).
In a condominium, many costs (caretaker, gardener, general electricity) are apportioned among all owners via a so-called value quota (thousandths shares). Even if you never use the lift, you still pay for its maintenance if you live on the 4th floor. This difference in solidarity between buying a flat and a house often leads to discussions at meetings.
Perhaps the most emotional difference between buying a flat and a house is decision-making.
In a house, autocracy reigns: you decide. In a flat, democracy reigns. Structural measures require a majority vote. If you want to paint the stairwell but the majority does not, it stays as it is. This difference between buying a flat and a house requires diplomacy and a willingness to compromise. Those who do not like to submit or vote are often unhappy with the flat model.
The structural difference between buying a flat and a house also defines the proximity to neighbours. In a house, you (usually) have distance to the property boundary. In an apartment, you live wall to wall. Noise emissions and consideration are a central issue here. The regulations often stipulate quiet hours that are stricter than the law. This difference between buying a flat and a house in everyday life should not be underestimated.
There is also a difference between buying a flat and a house when it comes to exit.
As land is a scarce commodity in Switzerland, detached houses (with large plots of land) often benefit more from increases in land prices than flats with a smaller share of the land value. On the other hand, flats are often more liquid, i.e. easier to sell, as the absolute price is usually lower. The difference between buying a flat and a house therefore also lies in the investment strategy: a house for maximum value appreciation (with high maintenance costs), a flat for slightly more liquidity and comfort.
In summary, the difference between buying a flat and a house is much more than the question of a garden or a balcony. It is a decision between two legal worlds. A house offers maximum freedom and privacy, but requires a high degree of personal responsibility and financial discipline in terms of reserves. A flat offers comfort and shared costs, but requires a willingness to submit to a community.
Anyone who understands the difference between buying a flat and a house knows that when you buy a house, you buy bricks and land, and when you buy a flat, you buy bricks and neighbours. Therefore, especially when buying a flat, check the "social software" of the building (minutes) just as meticulously as the building fabric.
Use Loft to find the right properties and have the legal documents checked impartially so that you can start your ownership journey with confidence.
Egal, welche Fragen du rund um Immobilien hast – Loft ist da, um sie dir übersichtlich, verständlich und zuverlässig zu beantworten.
Stelle Fragen zu einer Immobilie